Puffy is one of the most popular direct-to-consumer mattress dealers in the market now. Puffy is proudly Canadian-owned, and operated. Its proprietary foam technologies like their Cooling Cloud foam or Climate Comfort foam have made it a leader in the bedding market.
While Puffy remains one of the premier North American mattress deals that specialize in fully foam mattresses, they are by far not the only players vying for customer attention. How does Puffy hold up against some of the other popular brands out there? Let’s find out.
Before you continue, you may want to check out this video by Mattress Clarity on YouTube that gives a quick overview. After, you will want to read the rest of the article for a more comprehensive review.
The Puffy Mattress: A Review Bed In A Box Vs Puffy
Before getting into any of the comparisons, it’s good to review the ins and outs of Puffy as a mattress company, so we have a better sense of how it stacks up compared to the competition.
There are many types of mattresses available
Puffy has two mattresses available on its website, the Puffy Original and the Puffy Lux. The mattresses are available in a variety of sizes from Twin to California King. The construction of both mattresses is identical, except for the Puffy Lux’s extra foam layer that raises its mattress height to 12 inches (compared to the Puffy Original’s 10 inches).
Each Puffy mattress starts with its Cooling Cloud foam, a proprietary foam composition made by Puffy that ensures an even transfer of heat while maintaining a soft plush to better support your body while it sleeps. Climate Control foam and the firm support base are added to the Cooling Cloud foam top. Climate Control foam is an intermediary layer between top gel foam and bottom support base, increasing the mattress’s ability to regulate temperature. The support base serves as the final foundation of the entire mattress, giving it structure and preventing you from sinking too deep into the bed. The entire mattress was created with temperature regulation, spine alignment, pressure relief and temperature regulation in mind.
The Puffy Lux comes with an extra layer of foam, the Plush Dual Cloud Foam. This foam gives you two additional inches and helps to ease tension from long days. Both the Puffy Lux, and Original are covered in hypoallergenic and grippy bottom and top mattress covers.
Pricing Point for Mattresses
Price is always going to be a determining factor when it comes to deciding if the mattress will be the one for you. Puffy’s price point is in the middle of the spectrum. It is not too costly but not necessarily cheap.
An entry-level Puffy mattress, that is to say, their Twin sized original Puffy mattress, will set you back an easy CAD$750. Be aware that Queen-sized mattresses and beyond will cost you more than CAD$1,000. The Puffy Lux mattress will cost you more than CAD$2,000, and the exact size of the original is also available.
With all the ins and outs of Puffy accounted for, let’s now see how it matches up against some other popular brands online.
> > Click here to check out Puffy Mattress < <
Puffy Mattresses vs. Emma Mattresses
Emma is a common sight online these days, especially recently through their rigorous usage of online marketing. Puffy, a proudly Canadian business, is Emma’s source for their technologies. Their German-born designs are specifically geared towards temperature control as well as spinal alignment.
Will this European-designed bed be able to ship anywhere?
There are many types of mattresses available
Emma Original uses a proprietary foam technology similar to Puffy. It is designed to provide a plush and soft feel while still maintaining the structure of a mattress. This hybrid and balanced softness can be attributed to their memory foam and latex foam technologies. Their leading foam later used in all their mattresses is called Airgocell and is designed to adapt to pressure to better respond to body movements while sleeping.
Beneath this top layer of Airgocell is Emma’s visco-elastic memory foam, which acts as a secondary layer of plush foam between the Airgocell and the supportive base layer. Similar to Puffy’s Cooling Cloud foam construction, this layer is layered on top of the firm supportive core foam. Emma’s mattress’s supportive foundational foam, the bottom layer, has ridges around it. This is to help with spinal alignment and counter any pressure.
Unlike Puffy, Emma only sells the original version of their popular mattress. Emma does not sell Emma Lux or Emma Premier types, but the standard 10-inch mattress Emma uses to pull its entire catalog.
Pricing Point for Mattresses
Emma has only one type of mattress so it will be much easier to compare prices to Puffy’s original mattress. Emma certainly makes it much easier for new customers to try out their mattresses as their entry-level price point is at a low CAD$419 compared to Puffy’s CAD$700 twin-sized beds. Even Emma’s Queen size mattress comes in cheaper than Puffy’s twin size.
Also, Emma’s single mattress offering avoids any of the tough higher price choices that Puffy has. You won’t need to choose between a standard or premium version as Emma has backed all its focus on its standard size.
Final Winner
Choice-wise, Puffy does have Emma beat. You can choose from a variety of mattresses, including premium and original versions, as well as additional accessories such sheets, covers, pillows and bases.
But Emma does have one advantage on their side: price. Emma is a lot cheaper than Puffy, but offers the same premium comfort. Emma has similar customer protection plans, with warranties and trial plans identical to that of Puffy. Emma may be the right brand for you if you are new to the mattress market or don’t want to spend too much.
> > Click here to check out Puffy Mattress < <
Puffy Mattresses vs. Nectar Mattresses
We now have Nectar, a proudly New York-raised mattress manufacturer. Once viewed as one of the fastest-growing e-businesses in the US as well as a top place to work, Nectar promises a suite of different mattresses shipped directly to your door.
Nectar has similar foam technology to Puffy, and offers a wider range of mattresses. Will this more extensive catalog be what brings Nectar above Puffy as a bed brand?
There are many types of mattresses available
Nectar has not 1, not 2, but 3 total mattresses available on its website for purchase, all with varying degrees of softness, plushness, and even material compositions. Already Nectar has Puffy beat with the number of choices, but it’s still to be determined if more choices equal a better mattress brand.
Nectar’s first mattress is their original Nectar Memory Foam 12-inch mattress. This mattress comes with five separate layers, again similar to how Puffy designed its foam mattresses. Their Nectar Smart Layer is the first layer. This gel memory foam helps relieve pressure due to its high density construction.
The Nectar Smart Layer is then supported by two more foams, the Nectar Dynamic Support Layer and their Stay-Stable Support Layer. These foams help stabilize your body as you sleep, minimize motion transfer, and keep the mattress on the base. All this is enveloped in Nectar’s quilted Cool Cover, which helps regulate temperature, and Nectar’s shift-resistant lower cover, which allows stability by acting as an outer grip to the bed frame. If you’re looking for a mattress with a medium firmness that helps your body to be enveloped in memory foam while you sleep, the Nectar Memory Foam mattress might be good for you.
There is a Premier version of the Nectar Memory Foam mattress that looks similar to the Puffy and Puffylux versions. The Nectar Premier memory foam mattress has all the bells and whistles of the standard Nectar Memory Foam mattress. It also comes with an upgraded ActiveCoolHD ActiveSmart Layer that is thicker and more sophisticated. This additional inch of foam brings the total mattress height to 13-inches. It is specifically designed to further assist in keeping the mattress cool and regulating your body temperature while you sleep.
The Nectar Premier Copper mattress is the last and most expensive mattress available from Nectar. This mattress combines everything good about the previous two Nectar mattresses and adds more thickness to each layer. The mattress is 14 inches thick, so you won’t feel anything but the supportive and plushy comfort. To add to this, the maximum temperature regulating quilted cover is upgraded to include copper-infused threads that help dissipate heat and other heat conductive fibers that keep the mattress cool to the touch.
Price Point of Mattresses
If we’re talking about price points, then Nectar comes in reasonably affordable $499 for their Twin sized original memory foam mattress. These mattresses are available in a full size or larger at an additional $899.
Getting any of the premium versions will be a bit heavier on the pocket, naturally. The queen-sized Nectar Premier will set you back $1299, while you can get the more luxurious Nectar Premier Copper for $1699. These mattresses are still thicker than those offered by Puffy. The Puffy Lux is still more expensive than the Nectar mattresses in its largest size.
Nectar offers $399 worth of freebies with every purchase. These freebies can change according to the season, but usually include pillows, protectors, and mattress covers. Each purchase also comes with a lifetime warranty, a full-year trial, and free shipping to make the purchase that much easier.
Final Winner
Nectar appears to be a better choice than Puffy in terms of cost and the sheer number of options that are available to customers. Even the value of each purchase of a Nectar mattress is better by comparison as Nectar throws in additional freebies on top of the purchase itself.
The only flaw in Nectar would be the availability of its products to non-US residents. While Puffy exclusively ships to Canada, Nectar exclusively ships to the US. Your choice will eventually be dictated by where you are located in the world.
> > Click here to check out Puffy Mattress < <
Puffy Mattresses vs. Casper Mattresses
We had to include Casper. Casper was not included in a comparison of the best soft drinks. Casper’s high price is a common comparison with newer brands but it remains a top choice for many shoppers looking for a mattress.
Puffy uses Casper’s higher price points as a clear point to try out the cheaper Puffy mattress. Will Casper bow out to this newer Canadian brand?
Types of Mattresses Available
Unlike Puffy’s limited options, Casper impresses with four different mattresses to choose from, 3 of them having two variants each. This means that Casper has roughly seven mattresses you can choose from depending on your sleep style and preferences.
Casper’s first mattress, a traditional foam mattress, uses two layers of foam to construct its entire construction. This is Casper’s entry level mattress. It is known as the Element mattress. Casper’s Airscape perforated foam is used as the top layer on their mattresses. This allows heat to escape better while you sleep. Below this is their high-density foam base that prevents sagging and supports your whole body while you rest.
The Casper Original is next on the Casper catalog. Three layers of foam are used in the Casper Original. The first is the Airscape foam. This is followed by the Zoned Support Memory Foam. The Zoned Support foam is unique because it is essentially an area-specific memory foam, with some parts being firmer than others depending on which component needs more support (hence the term zoned).
The Casper Original can be purchased as a hybrid mattress. Hybrid mattresses have become more popular because they combine new memory foam technology and the reliable design of inner coils that are better than older mattresses. These Casper coils add lift to your bed and structural support to help you stay in bed when you need to and get out of it when you’re done.
The following two mattress types are much more premium than what we’ve seen previously. The Casper Nova Hybrid Snow Mattress is specifically designed for heat regulation. The mattress’s multilayer foam and coil technology is enhanced with cooling gels and thermal bands.
Lastly, the Wave Hybrid is Casper’s premium mattress with supportive sleep in mind. You can get this with the same cooling technology found in the Nova Hybrid Snow mattresses. However, the Wave’s selling point is its additional three layers of perforated foam, giving you the support you need without being overly stiff. Casper’s premium throughout bed design will provide you with the best spinal support and comfort.
Price Point of Mattresses
Casper’s biggest problem is its price. It’s no secret that Casper tends to edge towards the premium side when pricing their mattresses, but the price you’ll need to pay for some of their more premium mattresses is ridiculous at times. Bed In A Box Vs Puffy
Casper has its entry-level Element mattress at a manageable $545 for a twin size. Casper Element mattresses in queen sizes and larger will cost you at least $800.
The Original, Nova and Wave variants are all expensive. A queen-sized mattress is not cheap, so they cost over $1,000. The Nova and Wave variants double this number, while the Wave mattress is about $4,500.
Final Winner
Puffy is the clear winner here because of its simplicity and price. It won’t make sense for people on a budget to spend close to double for a Casper mattress when they can get a mattress that is just as good (or better at times) for a much more manageable price.
> > Click here to check out Puffy Mattress < <
Puffy Mattresses vs. Nolah Mattresses
Nolah, another American-owned mattress company, specializes in hybrid and foam mattresses. Nolah does not use outdated materials like the old memory foam and pure foam latex but rather their patented AirFoam mattress layers for all their mattresses. Bed In A Box Vs Puffy
Nolah’s foam claims to be 100 percent temperature neutral, providing better pressure relief for your joints. Let’s see how this compares to the mattresses Puffy has on offer.
Types of Mattresses Available
Nolah has three distinct mattresses on offer, the Noah Original 10-inch, the upgraded Nolah Signature 12-inch, and the luxury Nolah Evolution 15-inch mattress. The Signature and the Original share many similarities in construction as they are both fully foam mattresses. The Nolah Evolution proves to be the outlier as it is hybrid in design and uses Nolah’s bed inner-coil configuration.
The Original and Signature mattresses share the same first three layers of foam, the first being the layer of Nolah’s AirFoam to provide pressure relief and temperature regulation. These functions are further supported by the two additional layers of foam, the Deep Resilience Foam and High-Density Base Foam. The Signature mattress differs by adding extra thickness to its foam layers and having an extra firm AirFoam layer beneath the base foam so you can easily switch how firm or how plush you want your mattress to be. Bed In A Box Vs Puffy
Nolah’s Evolution mattress is Nolah’s best-selling model. This is due to the HDMax Eco Support Coils Nolah created to provide better pressure relief, additional cooling, and structural support around the edges.
Price Point of Mattresses
Despite being one of the newer direct-to-consumer mattresses out there, Nolah prices close to how higher-end mattress dealers price their mattresses. The starting Queen size Original mattress costs $899, and the Nolah Evolution doubles that to $1600. While it is not as bad as brands like Casper or Purple, it certainly isn’t a bargain by any means.
Final Winner
Nolah is still cheaper than Puffy, despite being more expensive in the price range. Nolah has more options than Puffy, which makes it a better mattress dealer. However, you will need to be in the United States to get their wide selection of mattresses.
> > Click here to check out Puffy Mattress < <
Puffy Mattress vs. DreamCloud Mattress
Our final contender for the list, DreamCloud’s mattresses are built with luxury in mind, without reaching inordinate prices. Specializing in hybrid mattresses, DreamCloud has endeavored to be an accessible brand for all while providing the same quality you can expect from legacy mattress brands. Bed In A Box Vs Puffy
Let’s see what else DreamCloud has to offer.
Types of Mattresses Available
DreamCloud sells three mattress on their website: the DreamCloud original and DreamCloud Premier. The bed’s hybrid coil-and-foam construction is similar. However, the higher-end models have more layers and thickness.
Five essential layers are required to make the DreamCloud original and all DreamCloud mattresses. Their gel memory foam is the first layer. It contours to your body as you sleep. This is then supported by their Sink-In-Just-Right layer, the Targeted Support Coil layer, and the essential base foam layer, which all help the top layer provide optimum comfort without sacrificing support. To give the mattress a cool and soft touch, they have added a cashmere-quilted top layer. Bed In A Box Vs Puffy
The DreamCloud Premier Rest and DreamCloud Premier Rest are identical mattresses. They have additional layers of foam and higher support coils. The Premier Rest gives the Premier Rest a higher height. This is the main difference between the two mattresses. Each Premier version comes with pressure-relieving foam layers and enhanced support layers, all designed with your optimum comfort in mind.
Price Point of Mattresses
DreamCloud has three mattress options, each with varying quality. However, their entry-level pricing is $699 for the Twin size original mattress. Although some DreamCloud models can be quite expensive, they don’t exceed $2,000 in price. This is a huge feat for a brand that creates a more complex hybrid mattress without increasing prices. Bed In A Box Vs Puffy
Every purchase comes with $399 worth goods such as additional pillows, mattress protectors and sheets. You can rest assured that your DreamCloud purchase comes with a lifetime warranty as well as a full year of no-strings-attached sleeping trial.
Final Winner
DreamCloud’s mattresses are more flexible and supportive than traditional memory foam mattresses Puffy, while still being affordable. If you’re part of DreamCloud’s serviceable areas, we would highly suggest trying one out for you.
In Summary Bed In A Box Vs Puffy
It seems that Puffy is correct about its claim of being more accessible in price than Casper. Compared to what other brands are currently doing now, Puffy appears to be lagging in terms of price, functionality, and reach.
Puffy will be a top choice for Canadian residents. But if you’re a US resident, you won’t be able to get Puffy to your doorstep anyway, so we recommend going with another brand that services the US directly. DreamCloud’s innovative hybrid technologies are what we think would be the best among all brands. We recommend visiting their website if you’re looking for a mattress.